37Necklaces Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged

Aged for a full 24 months, 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar represents the golden mean of Wisconsin cheesemaking. This patient aging process naturally develops a bold, pronounced sharpness and a rich depth of flavor without losing the smooth, meltable consistency that makes cheddar so versatile.

Crafted with premium milk from local Wisconsin family dairies, this classic yellow cheddar brings a robust bite and traditional farmhouse character to any board or recipe.

Texture:

Firm and pleasantly crumbly, yet smooth enough to slice cleanly and melt creamily.

Flavor:

Bold, tangy, and extra sharp with a rich, buttery body and a lingering, savory finish.

Perfect Pairings:

🍷 Sip: Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Pale Ale, Stout, or a classic Brandy Old Fashioned.

🥖 Chew: Usinger’s Beef Summer Sausage, Underground Meats Calabrian 3-Way Salami, water crackers, or tart apple slices. 

🍴 Make: Shred into ultimate gourmet mac and cheese, layer into classic bacon grilled cheese, or anchor an authentic Wisconsin charcuterie board.